- 1797-1897 - The First 100 Years
- 1898-1956
- 1898-1902 (Earnest F. Ford)
- 1902-1906 (Charles Jewell Burton)
- 1906-1907 (Reverend R. Jay Roberts)
- 1907-1909 (Reverend Elbert Henry Conrad)
- 1909-1911 - (Daniel John Bloxham)
- 1911-1917 (Theodore) Byron Caldwell
- 1917 (Charles Burton Allnatt)
- 1917-1923 (Reverend Royden Nelson Rand)
- 1923-1928 (Reverend James MacPherson)
- 1928-1938 (Reverend Derwood Lester Smith)
- 1938-1945 (Reverend Lawrence Albert Wheaton)
- 1945-1956 (Reverend John J. Baker)
- 1957-1989
- 1990's
- 2000's